Because there has been a shocking amount of discourse over this.
Evidently we need to discuss the best course of action regarding page creation, important/unimportant information, what constitutes an unnecessary page, etc, and hopefully arrive at a compromise for the sake of the wiki.
I have indeed read both Lunt's and FieryFury's blog posts, and I invite them (and anyone who wants to pitch in) to express their opinions here. Time and comments have already been wasted in back and forth banter, so be extremely direct and succinct in presenting your idea.
Questions to address, from what I've seen: What is the Weapons page's purpose? Should existing weapons be listed on said page? What defines an important weapon? Which weapons deserve a separate, unique page?
These can be expanded to more general issues: What information should this wiki ultimately contain? On what basis should new pages be created, and pages added? What information is significant? What's the line between canon/fanon (e.g. fan characters)?
I am forming my own opinion on these matters too, but I'd like to clearly understand both positions before proceeding.